If you’re a teen looking for a safe, reliable, and confidence-inspiring first vehicle, Subaru should be at the top of your list. Known for its industry-leading safety technologies, standard Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive on most models, and long-term reliability, Subaru continues to earn recognition from automotive safety experts. 

For families throughout Smithtown, Commack, St. James, Kings Park, Huntington, East Northport, Hauppauge, and surrounding Long Island communities, choosing the right vehicle for a new driver is one of the most important decisions they’ll make. Safety, reliability, and confidence behind the wheel are essential when selecting a first car. 

In its latest announcement, Subaru revealed that nine vehicles were jointly recommended by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and Consumer Reports as ideal choices for teen drivers, including both new and used models. This recognition reinforces Subaru’s reputation as one of the best automotive brands for young and inexperienced drivers. 

Whether you’re a first-time driver, a parent shopping for your teenager, or simply researching the safest vehicles on the road, this guide covers the top Subaru models recommended for teen drivers and explains why they stand out from the competition. 

Key Takeaways

• Recommended vehicles must meet strict standards for crashworthiness, handling, braking performance, and ease of use.
• Most Subaru vehicles include standard Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive, enhancing traction and stability.
• Subaru’s advanced driver-assistance technologies help reduce the risk of common crashes.
• Models like the Forester, Outback, Legacy, and Crosstrek consistently rank among the safest vehicles in their segments.
• Both new and used Subaru models offer excellent value for families seeking a dependable first vehicle.

Why Subaru Is One of the Best Brands for Teen Drivers

Teen drivers face a significantly higher risk of accidents due to limited driving experience. That’s why experts recommend vehicles that prioritize:

• Crash protection
• Stable handling
• Strong braking performance
• Driver-assistance technology
• Visibility
• Reliability

Subaru excels in all these categories.

Many Subaru models come equipped with advanced safety features such as:

• Automatic Emergency Braking
• Lane Departure Warning
• Adaptive Cruise Control
• Blind-Spot Monitoring
• Rear Cross-Traffic Alert

Additionally, Subaru’s renowned Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system provides enhanced traction in rain, snow, and challenging road conditions, helping young drivers maintain control when conditions become less than ideal. This can be especially valuable during Long Island’s winter weather and rainy driving conditions experienced throughout Smithtown, Huntington, Commack, and nearby areas. 

Subaru Models Named “Best Choice” for Teen Drivers

Subaru Crosstrek Plug-In Hybrid (2019–2023)

The Subaru Crosstrek Plug-In Hybrid combines the versatility of a compact crossover with enhanced fuel efficiency.

Why It Works for Teens

• Elevated ride height improves visibility
• Standard all-wheel drive
• Excellent safety ratings
• Practical cargo space for school, sports, and road trips

Parents appreciate its balance of efficiency and safety, while teens often enjoy its modern styling and comfortable ride.

Subaru Legacy (2020–2025)

The Subaru Legacy remains one of the safest midsize sedans available.

Standout Features

• Smooth ride quality
• Excellent crash protection
• Standard EyeSight Driver Assist Technology
• Comfortable interior

For families in St. James, Nesconset, and Smithtown seeking a traditional sedan with advanced safety systems, the Legacy is an outstanding choice. 

Subaru Outback (2020–2025)

Part wagon, part SUV, the Subaru Outback has become one of the brand’s most popular vehicles.

Benefits for Teen Drivers

• Excellent outward visibility
• Advanced driver-assistance features
• Spacious interior
• Standard all-wheel drive
• High safety scores

The Outback is especially attractive for active families who enjoy road trips, outdoor adventures, and all-weather capability.

Subaru Forester (2019–2025)

The Subaru Forester consistently ranks among the safest compact SUVs on the market.

Why Parents Love It

• Exceptional visibility
• Easy-to-use controls
• Strong crash-test performance
• Spacious seating
• Reliable ownership experience

Its straightforward design helps reduce distractions, making it an excellent vehicle for inexperienced drivers. Many parents in Huntington, Commack, and Kings Park appreciate the Forester’s balance of safety, practicality, and long-term value. 

Subaru Solterra (2023–2025)

The all-electric Subaru Solterra offers a modern option for environmentally conscious families.

Key Advantages

• Advanced safety technology
• Electric efficiency
• Standard all-wheel drive
• Comfortable ride quality

As EV adoption continues to grow across Long Island, the Solterra provides a safe and practical entry point for young drivers. 

Subaru Models Named “Good Choice” for Teen Drivers

Subaru Impreza Sedan or Wagon (2014–2025)

The Impreza remains one of the most affordable entries into Subaru ownership.

Highlights

• Standard all-wheel drive
• Compact size for easier parking
• Excellent reliability
• Strong safety reputation

Its manageable dimensions make it particularly appealing for new drivers navigating local roads, school parking lots, and busier shopping areas around Commack and Huntington. 

Subaru Crosstrek (2016–2025)

The Crosstrek has become a favorite among younger buyers.

Why It’s Popular

• SUV-inspired styling
• Elevated seating position
• Excellent visibility
• Proven reliability

The Crosstrek provides confidence-inspiring handling while remaining practical and fuel-efficient, making it a popular choice for students and young professionals throughout Suffolk County. 

Subaru Legacy (2015–2019)

Earlier Legacy models continue to provide exceptional value in the used vehicle market.

Benefits

• Affordable pricing
• Proven durability
• Comfortable ride
• Strong safety performance

Families seeking a budget-friendly option can often find these models at attractive price points while still benefiting from Subaru’s safety-focused engineering. 

What Makes Subaru Safer Than Many Competitors?

While many automakers offer safety technologies, Subaru’s commitment to standardizing key features across its lineup helps set the brand apart.

Key advantages include:

Standard Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive

Unlike many competitors that charge extra for all-wheel drive, Subaru includes it on most vehicles. This improves:

• Stability
• Cornering performance
• Wet-weather traction
• Snow driving confidence

EyeSight Driver Assist Technology

Subaru’s EyeSight system uses cameras to monitor traffic conditions and assist drivers by:

• Detecting potential collisions
• Applying emergency braking
• Maintaining safe following distances
• Reducing lane departure incidents

Excellent Crash-Test Performance

Subaru vehicles consistently perform well in independent crash testing, providing peace of mind for both parents and young drivers.

Final Thoughts

Choosing a vehicle for a teen driver is one of the most important automotive decisions a family can make. Safety, reliability, ease of operation, and long-term value should all play a major role in the decision-making process.

The fact that nine Subaru models earned recommendations from both the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and Consumer Reports highlights the brand’s continued leadership in safety and dependability.

Whether you’re considering a used Subaru Legacy, a versatile Crosstrek, a family-friendly Outback, or a highly rated Forester, Subaru offers multiple options that can help young drivers build confidence behind the wheel while providing parents with additional peace of mind. 

For drivers and families throughout Smithtown, Commack, St. James, Huntington, Kings Park, Hauppauge, and surrounding Long Island communities, Subaru continues to be one of the smartest choices for first-time drivers thanks to its outstanding commitment to safety, reliability, and all-weather confidence. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the safest Subaru for a teen driver?

The Subaru Forester is often considered one of the safest choices due to its excellent visibility, strong crash-test scores, easy-to-use controls, and advanced driver-assistance technologies.

Is Subaru a good first car for teenagers?

Yes. Subaru vehicles are widely recommended because of their safety ratings, reliability, all-wheel-drive capability, and driver-assistance features.

Why do IIHS and Consumer Reports recommend Subaru?

Subaru models consistently perform well in crash testing, braking, handling, and usability evaluations while offering advanced safety technologies designed to help prevent accidents.

Is a used Subaru safe for a teen driver?

Many used Subaru models, including the Legacy, Crosstrek, and Impreza, remain highly recommended due to their proven safety records and long-term durability.

Which Subaru is best for a college student?

The Subaru Crosstrek is often considered one of the best choices because it combines affordability, versatility, fuel efficiency, and strong safety performance.