Meet our Team

Owner

Nancy Buzzetta

President

Nancy Buzzetta is a professional in Automotive Retail recently celebrating 30  years of work at the Competition Automotive Group (CAG), where she is a managing partner. Nancy holds a Bachelor of Science degree from the  University of Vermont in Business Administration with a concentration in  Accounting. Prior to joining the family’s Automotive business, Nancy worked in the banking and accounting industries and earned her CPA certification from the Vermont  State board of accountancy. Concurrent with her professional career, she has worked in pursuit of her other passions; wellness, fitness, equestrian sports, and animal welfare. Nancy enjoys an active role in the oversight of the CAG, which currently spans 5  franchised dealerships featuring the brands of Mercedes-Benz, Sprinter Vans,  BMW, Subaru and Genesis. The company employs more than 500 people on Long Island. When not at work, Nancy loves spending time at home with her husband, Pablo  Triana, her children, and many pets including 6 rescue dogs! They love to travel and spend time in the great outdoors. She was born with a passion for horses and rides almost every morning. She is a competitive equestrian at the national level and competes at some of the largest and most prestigious shows in the country. She recently won a top 10 placing in a national championship class as well as earning multiple placings at the 2023 National Horse Show. In addition to her interest in helping animals, Nancy is involved with a number of other local organizations including Three Village School District’s Industry  Advisory Board, Old Field Farm Ltd of Setauket, Celebrate St. James, Paws of  War, and Pawsitive Possibilities dog and cat rescue; as well she serves on the  Retailer Advisory Board for Subaru Distributors Corporation. Nancy and her team at CAG are working to decrease the company’s environmental footprint one step at a time. The CAG recycles almost all shop output and is working on an internal education program to help our team to minimize waste at the stores. The CAG has one solar array already working and is hoping to add to it in 2024. In addition, CAG participates in the One Tree  Planted initiative. Nancy has long been a believer that the key to the continued success of the  CAG relies heavily upon our reputation in the community, and is committed to provision of an outstanding client experience.

Management

Nino
Tiburzi

General Sales Manager

Reggie
Watkins

Sales Manager

Justin
Stein

Sales Manager

Chris
Barcelo

Service Operations Manager

Matthew Adler

Pre-Owned Sales Manger

With 15 years in the automotive industry - all of them proudly representing Subaru, Nino brings a wealth of experience and passion to the Competition Auto Group team. Over the past six years at CAG, he has held key roles including Sales Representative, Sales Manager, and currently General Sales Manager. What drives him most is the opportunity to lead, motivate, and inspire the sales team every day. Outside of work, Nino enjoys quality time with his wife and three children, catching up on movies and shows, cooking up some new recipes, and cheering on the Yankees, Knicks, and Giant!

29 years in the automotive industry
as of November 2025 I will have been here 8 wonderful years
Throughout the years in this business I have worked my way up from salesperson to a finance manager and now salesmanger.
My favorite part is assisting the salespeople and help make the customers happy Competition customers.
I love to travel. Exploring the world and seeing new places.
In my spare time I chauffeur my children around as well as root on all NY sports teams.

With 21 years in the automotive industry, I’ve spent the past 15 proudly representing the Subaru brand - and the last 7 of those with Competition Automotive Group. Over the years, I’ve worn many hats, from Advisor to Assistant Manager to Service Manager… and yes, even Supreme Overlord (unofficially, of course). What drives me every day is the opportunity to develop my team, watch them grow, and celebrate their success - all while serving the best customers in the industry. Subaru isn’t just a brand I work for; it’s a community I believe in.

Outside the shop, you’ll find me reading tarot, making music, or heading out on outdoor adventures - always seeking inspiration and a little bit of magic along the way.

With 20 years of experience in the automotive industry, I’ve had the opportunity to work in a variety of roles, from Internet Sales and Used Car Sales to Assistant Sales Manager, Acquisition Manager, and New Car Desking. Each role has contributed to my growth and deepened my understanding of the business.

For the past 2+ years, I’ve been proud to be part of the Competition Automotive Group, where I’ve had the pleasure of working with a supportive and driven team.

What I love most about my job is seeing the joy a car can bring to a customer - it’s like when a pet finds a new home. Being part of that moment is truly special.

When I’m not at work, you’ll find me spending time with my family or indulging my passion for cars by working on and riding my go-karts and dune buggies. Anything with wheels and an engine is my kind of adventure!

Sales

Jeff
Barkan

Sales and Leasing Consultant

Cathy
Kelleher

Sales and Leasing Consultant

Rodney
McCabe

Sales and Leasing Consultant

Lisa
Cain

Sales and Leasing Consultant

Robert
Tutino

Sales and Leasing Consultant

Joe
Giampietro

Sales and Leasing Consultant

Zaak
Fox

Sales and Leasing Consultant

Kirk
Anderson

Pre-owned Sales Consultant

Jose Diego
Otanez Espinal

Pre Owned Sales Consultant

Farrell Shapiro

Sales And Leasing Consultant

Regina
Medina

Subaru Star Delivery Specialist

Ashley
De Pena

Sales and Leasing Consultant

Cooper Mankowski

Sales and Leasing Consultant

Frank Mora

Pre-owned Sales Consultant

Jesse Moss

Sales And Leasing Consultant

Jeff came to us from Thomas Subaru in Port Jefferson Station. His knowledge of the Subaru product, combined with years of experience in a managerial position, makes Jeff an excellent addition to our Subaru team. Visit us here at Competition Subaru of Smithtownn, and see what all the buzz is about! Competition Subaru of Smithtown is proud to feature the highest-quality personnel, from management to sales, service to parts, our Competition Subaru of Smithtown repair facility, and Subaru sales for Suffolk County and Long Island will exceed your expectations! Call Competition Subaru of Smithtown at 888-604-0343. ** SUBARU LEGACY OWNER **

With over 32 years of experience in the automotive industry, I’ve had the privilege of spending the last 23 years representing the Subaru brand and celebrating 15 years with Competition Subaru this July. My journey has included a variety of roles—from Biller, Bookkeeper, and Office Manager to Sales, where I’ve found my true passion. What I enjoy most is building long-term relationships with my customers and getting to know their families and friends along the way. As a proud owner of both a Subaru Forester and a Subaru Impreza, and someone born and raised right here in Smithtown, Subaru is more than just a brand to me - it’s a part of my everyday life. ** SUBARU FORESTER & IMPREZA OWNER **

With 35 years in the automotive industry and 8 years proudly representing Subaru, I’ve built a career rooted in customer care and connection. Over the years, I’ve held positions in Sales and as an Assistant Sales Manager, always striving to make the car-buying experience smooth, enjoyable, and memorable.

What I love most about my job is the opportunity to help others and bring a smile to someone’s face - it’s what keeps me passionate about what I do.

Outside of work, I enjoy biking and, most importantly, spending time with my children and grandchildren. I also have a lifelong love for music — after playing in a rock band for many years, I still enjoy picking up the drums or guitar whenever I get the chance.

Fluent in Italian

I’ve been in the automotive industry for 7 years, all of which I’ve proudly spent representing the same trusted brand. During this time, I’ve worked as a Sales Consultant, focusing on building strong customer relationships and delivering the best possible service.

What I enjoy most about my job is working with people - helping them find the right vehicle and creating a positive, memorable experience along the way.

Outside of work, I enjoy spending quality time with my family and friends.

** SUBARU FORESTER OWNER **

With 43 years of experience in the automotive industry, I’ve had the opportunity to serve in nearly every role - from Sales and Finance Manager to General Manager and Dealer Principal. For the past 6 years, I’ve been proud to be part of the Competition Automotive Group as a Sales Representative, helping customers find the perfect vehicle to fit their needs.

What I enjoy most about my job is meeting new people and making the car-buying process as smooth and rewarding as possible.

Outside of the dealership, I’m an active member of the Stony Brook Fire Department and recently completed an 8-year tenure in the Chief’s office, now serving as an Ex-Chief and EMT. When I’m not volunteering, I’m spending time with my amazing wife and our 10 grandchildren, who definitely keep us on our toes!

** SUBARU OUTBACK OWNER **

With over 35 years of experience at Subaru of America in Fixed Operations, Service, and Sales & Marketing, I’ve dedicated my career to the Subaru brand. For the past 9 years, I’ve been proud to continue that journey at Competition Subaru, specializing in sales and inventory management. On the weekends, you’ll find me behind the wheel of my Subaru Ascent, exploring the charm of Long Island - from antique shops to historic sites. I’m also passionate about golf, rally car racing, all things sports, and spending time in nature.

** SUBARU ASCENT OWNER **

With 19 years of experience in the automotive industry and 9 years specializing in Subaru vehicles, I’m proud to serve as a Sales and Leasing Advisor at CAG. For over 3 years, I’ve been helping clients find the perfect vehicle while providing a friendly, transparent, and enjoyable buying experience. My goal is simple: make sure every customer drives away with a smile. When I’m not at the dealership, I enjoy traveling, road trips, visiting the beach, trying new restaurants, and spending time with friends. At home, I love cooking and caring for my cat.

With 11 years of experience in the automotive industry and 5 of those proudly spent with Subaru and Competition Automotive Group, I serve as a dedicated Sales Consultant. My favorite part of the job is assisting clients-helping them find the right vehicle and making the process smooth and enjoyable. Outside of work, I cherish spending time with my grandchildren.

I’ve been in the automotive industry for about 14 years - though honestly, some days it feels more like dog years! For the past 3 (and counting), I’ve been part of the team here at Competition Automotive Group.

Officially, I’m in sales. Unofficially? I’m the self-proclaimed best salesman around. What do I love most about my job? Like most people... my days off.

Outside of work, I love spending time with my daughters and doing a little bit of everything - except fishing (I get seasick). Cooking, eating, and enjoying the good things in life are always high on the list!

*Fluent in Spanish*

I've been with Competition Subaru since March 2021. I'm a proud husband and father of three teenage girls. I've been playing piano for over 40 years and am a lifelong, die-hard fan of the Mets, Jets, and Knicks.

** SUBARU ASCENT OWNER **

I’ve been in the car business for 8 years and have spent the last 2 years as part of the team at Competition Automotive Group.

One of my favorite parts of working in car sales is helping customers find the perfect vehicle that suits both their lifestyle and budget. There’s something incredibly rewarding about seeing someone drive off with a smile, knowing I helped make that moment happen.

In my spare time, I love to travel and explore new places. Each trip brings new experiences, interesting people, and unforgettable memories.

Fluent in Spanish

Service

Tommy Santoro

Head Service Advisor

Joyce
Calderone

Service Advisor

Michael
Giardinello

Service Advisor

Michael Fiandor

Service Advisor

Kait Curti

Service Advisor

Matt
Fowler

Shop Foreman

Thomas Santoro has been within the automotive industry since 1983! He has been with Competition Subaru of Smithtown since December of 2022 and is always available to help you and answer any and all questions about our efficient Service Department or about your favorite Subaru vehicle! Tommy is so passionate about his job and loves watching his co-workers success alongside him. His favorite part of his job is helping our newer Service Advisors succeed within their careers to help make our Service Department as professional and speedy as possible! Teamwork truly makes the dream work! In Tommy's spare time, he enjoys cooking, working out and golfing!

** SUBARU ASCENT OWNER **

With 12 years in the automotive industry, I bring both hands-on experience and customer-focused service to my role. I’ve been with Subaru and Competition Automotive Group for just over 2 years, currently serving as a Service Advisor. Prior to joining CAG, I worked as a mechanic, which gave me a strong technical foundation that I now use to help customers understand their vehicle needs. My favorite part of the job is helping customers stay safely on the road by working closely with our technicians to complete necessary repairs. Outside of work, I enjoy spending quality time with my family.

Parts

John Giannetto

Parts Manager

Anthony
Amelia

Parts Specialist

Laura Van Winckel

Parts Specialist

Michael Fowler

Parts Specialist

Thomas Morra

Parts Specialist

Reception

Jackie
Scurry

Receptionist

Lois
Cantore

Receptionist

Jackie is our receptionist, she will likely be the first person you see when you visit us here at Competition Subaru of Smithtown, located in Saint James, NY. We are happy to have Jackie as part of our Subaru Team, and a part of the Competition Automotive Group. Competition Subaru of Smithtown is proud to feature the highest-quality personnel, from management to sales, service to parts, our Competition Subaru of Smithtown repair facility and Subaru sales for Suffolk County and Long Island, will exceed your expectations! ** SUBARU OUTBACK OWNER **

Finance Team

Rahul Verma

Business Manager

Lovelle Fenico

Business Manager

With over 10 years of experience in the automotive Industry, I currently serve as Business Manager at Competition Subaru, where I help clients navigate vehicle financing with confidence and clarity. I take pride in combining deep industry knowledge with a client-first approach to create a smooth, transparent buying experience. Outside of work, you’ll find me chasing new adventures—whether it’s exploring new destinations, hitting the slopes, or spending quality time with my family.

Business Development Team

Diana
Bautista

Customer Care Advocate

Corinne
Johnsen

Trade-up Sales Consultant

Donna
Savino

Service Coordinator

I’ve been in the automotive industry for 3 years, all of which I’ve proudly spent with Competition Subaru as a Customer Advocate. While my time in the car business may be recent, I’ve spent nearly 30 years working directly with customers - and I’ve learned just how unique, interesting, and wonderful people truly are. Helping customers and creating positive experiences is something I genuinely enjoy.

My passion for cars comes from my hero - my father, Cheo - who is still a mechanic at 75 years old. Growing up, I watched him build and race street cars in the Bronx, and that love for the automotive world stuck with me. To this day, walking through the Subaru service department each morning brings back those memories, the smells, the sounds - it all reminds me of him.

Outside of work, I love sports and cherish time spent with my family and friends. My kids make me so proud, and my grandkids are simply amazing. And one day soon… the Subaru BRZ will be mine - it’s definitely my favorite!

I’ve been in the automotive industry for 9½ years - all of them proudly spent with the same brand and at Competition Automotive Group. During that time, I’ve held roles as a Service Cashier and BDC Consultant, gaining valuable experience and building strong connections with both customers and coworkers.

What I enjoy most about my job is being a problem solver and helping customers. There’s something really rewarding about being able to assist and make someone’s day a little easier.

Outside of work, I love all things creative - from crafting and gardening to exploring antique shops. I’m also an avid reader in a local book club and enjoy going out to dinner with friends and family whenever I can.

With over 11 years of experience in the automotive industry - including the last 4 proudly serving in the BDC Service Department at Subaru - Donna brings a passion for helping people to everything she does. Known for her friendly demeanor and dedication to customer care, she’s a valued member of the team. Outside of work, Donna loves cooking, spending time with family and friends, going to concerts, watching sports, and relaxing with the Hallmark Channel.

Dealer Info

Phone Numbers:Sales Hours:Special Hours
  • Mother's DayClosed
  • Memorial DayClosed
  • Father's DayClosed
  • 4th of JulyClosed
Regular Hours
  • Mon - Fri9:00 AM - 8:00 PM
  • Sat9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Sun11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Service Hours:Special Hours
  • Mother's DayClosed
  • Memorial DayClosed
  • Father's DayClosed
  • 4th of JulyClosed
Regular Hours
  • Mon - Fri7:30 AM - 5:30 PM
  • Sat8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
  • SunClosed
Parts Hours:Special Hours
  • Mother's DayClosed
  • Memorial DayClosed
  • Father's DayClosed
  • 4th of JulyClosed
Regular Hours
  • Mon - Fri7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
  • Sat8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
  • SunClosed

Menu

Get Directions

601 Middle Country Road, St James, NY, 11780
Competition Subaru of Smithtown 40.8608728, -73.157779.