Smithtown vs. St. James: Why Competition Subaru Proudly Calls Both Places Home

A Tale of Two Towns: Our Unique Long Island Roots

Here at Competition Subaru, we often get asked a very specific question by our first-time customers: “If your name is Competition Subaru of Smithtown, why is your address in St. James?” It is a fair question that speaks to the unique, deeply interconnected geography of our local Long Island community. The truth is, we suffer from a bit of a geographical identity crisis—but we embrace it wholeheartedly. While our physical footprint and official mailing address are located in the beautiful hamlet of St. James, our dealership has been woven into the fabric of the greater Smithtown community for decades. Rather than choosing between the two, we proudly celebrate our role in serving both of these incredible towns.

Bridging the Gap on Middle Country Road

Geographical borders on Long Island can sometimes blur, but community ties remain strong. Our expansive showroom and state-of-the-art service center are strategically located at 601 Middle Country Road, St. James, NY 11780.

Because we sit right on the bustling Route 25 corridor, we are perfectly positioned to act as a bridge between the two townships. Whether spending a Saturday afternoon shopping at the nearby Smith Haven Mall, dropping the kids off at St. Patrick’s School, or enjoying the historic charm of the Village of the Branch, our dealership is just minutes away. This prime location allows us to provide the localized, family-owned touch of a neighborhood dealership while offering the massive inventory and premium amenities expected from Long Island’s elite automotive retailers.

The Premier Subaru Dealer in St James, NY

For drivers searching for a reliable Subaru dealer in St James, NY, Competition Subaru offers an unparalleled automotive experience. The rugged, all-weather capability of the Subaru brand is a perfect match for the active lifestyles of North Shore residents.

Whether you need a versatile Subaru Outback to haul your kayaks down to the Nissequogue River, or a dependable Subaru Crosstrek to navigate unpredictable New York winters on your commute via Jericho Turnpike, our expert team is here to help. We are incredibly proud to be the premier automotive destination for the residents of St. James, providing not only new and pre-owned vehicle sales but also factory-certified Subaru maintenance and genuine OEM parts.

Directions to Competition Subaru: Your Local Automotive Hub

Getting to our dealership is incredibly straightforward, no matter which town you call home. If you are looking for quick directions to Competition Subaru, simply hop onto Middle Country Road (Route 25).

• From Downtown Smithtown: Head east on E Main Street, continuing onto Jericho Turnpike/Middle Country Road. We are located less than 10 minutes away, just past Lake Avenue, on your left.
• From the Smith Haven Mall: Head west on Middle Country Road. After a short, 5-minute drive, you will find our expansive Subaru showroom on your right.

No matter where you are traveling from, the team at Competition Subaru of Smithtown—proudly operating in St. James—is ready to welcome you to the family.

Frequently Asked Questions About Competition Subaru’s Location & Services

Is Competition Subaru located in Smithtown or St. James?

Competition Subaru is officially located in St. James, NY. However, because our dealership sits right on the border along Middle Country Road and has historically served the greater township, our official name is Competition Subaru of Smithtown. We proudly call both communities home.

What is the physical address for Competition Subaru?

The physical address for Competition Subaru is 601 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780. Our location is easily accessible from Jericho Turnpike and is just minutes away from the Smith Haven Mall.

Are you the closest Subaru dealer in St James, NY?

Yes. Competition Subaru is the premier Subaru dealer in St James, NY. We offer an expansive inventory of new and Certified Pre-Owned Subaru vehicles, as well as an advanced, factory-certified service center right in the heart of St. James.

How do I get directions to Competition Subaru from the Smith Haven Mall?

Getting directions to Competition Subaru from the Smith Haven Mall is incredibly easy. Simply exit the mall area and head west on Middle Country Road (Route 25) for approximately two miles. Competition Subaru will be on your right.

Does Competition Subaru service vehicles for residents of both towns?

Absolutely. The certified service center at Competition Subaru provides expert preventative maintenance, major mechanical repairs, and genuine Subaru parts to drivers from St. James, Smithtown, Huntington, and throughout the entire North Shore of Long Island.

What are the sales hours for Competition Subaru?

The showroom at Competition Subaru is open Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 8:00 PM, Saturday from 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 5:00 PM. We invite you to visit us at your earliest convenience.

Where can I find reviews for Competition Subaru?

You can read hundreds of verified, five-star reviews for Competition Subaru directly on our Google Business Profile, DealerRater, and CARFAX. We take great pride in our reputation for transparency and exceptional customer service across the Smithtown and St. James communities.