Competition Subaru of Smithtown

Blog

Compare 2025 Subaru Crosstrek vs 2025 Subaru Forester

2025 Subaru Crosstrek 2025 Subaru Forester

Engine

2.0L 4-Cylinder 2.5L 4-Cylinder

Horsepower

152 hp 180 hp

MPG (City/Highway)

27/34 * 26/33 *

Hybrid Model

Not available Available

Rear Leg Room

36.5 inches 39.6 inches

Max Cargo Space

54.7 cubic feet 74.4 cubic feet

2025 Subaru Crosstrek vs 2025 Subaru Forester

Serving St James, NY

For Long Island drivers searching for adventure-ready crossovers with elevated ride height, smart utility, and standard all-wheel drive, the 2025 Subaru Crosstrek and 2025 Subaru Forester stand out as top contenders. Both models deliver the confidence, comfort, and versatility Subaru is known for—making them ideal for everything from Stony Brook commutes to weekend road trips across New York.

Performance

Both SUVs feature Subaru’s Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive and a CVT (Continuously Variable Transmission) to ensure smooth power delivery and all-weather traction. Here’s how they stack up. The 2025 Crosstrek offers a 2.0L BOXER® engine with 152 horsepower on base trims and a 2.5L BOXER® engine with 182 horsepower on Sport, Limited, and Wilderness trims.

The 2025 Forester comes standard with a 2.5L BOXER® engine producing 180 horsepower (up to 182 hp on Wilderness trim). Whether you’re navigating snowy roads in Setauket or exploring backroads near Port Jefferson, both models are built for confident year-round driving.

Appearance

Style-conscious buyers will appreciate the distinct looks of each SUV. The Crosstrek brings a more athletic flair, while the Forester leans into traditional SUV ruggedness.

The Crosstrek highlights:

  • A sportier silhouette with bold character lines and sculpted curves
  • High-contrast black cladding and fog light surrounds
  • A wide, aggressive grille with angular LED headlamps

The Forester stands out with:

  • A boxier, upright stance for a more classic SUV profile
  • Squared-off fender flares and smoothed-out side panels
  • A layered grille design with trapezoidal headlights and rugged accents

From off-road style to urban edge, Competition Subaru of St. James has the perfect design to match your lifestyle.

Features

Both the Crosstrek and Forester offer generous technology, comfort, and safety options that enhance every drive around Suffolk County. Shared highlights include:

  • Available StarTexâ„¢ or leather-trimmed seating with heated front seats
  • An 11.6-inch STARLINK® infotainment touchscreen with wireless Apple CarPlay® & Android Autoâ„¢
  • Harman Kardon® premium audio, built-in navigation, and multiple USB ports
  • EyeSight® Driver Assist Technology with pre-collision braking, lane keep assist, and blind-spot detection

The Forester adds extra innovation, including:

  • DriverFocus® Distraction Mitigation System
  • Surround-view camera and front-facing camera for safer parking
  • Gesture control and a digital rearview mirror for added driving ease

If advanced safety tech is a top priority, the Forester brings more features to your daily drive.

Test Drive the 2025 Crosstrek or Forester at Competition Subaru in St. James, NY

Still deciding which Subaru SUV is right for your family or adventure? Come to Competition Subaru in St. James, NY to compare the 2025 Crosstrek and Forester side by side. From financing to service, our friendly team is ready to guide you every step of the way.

* EPA-estimated fuel economy. Actual mileage may vary.

Recommended Posts

2026 Subaru Crosstrek

Here's Why We're Excited About the 2026 Subaru Crosstrek

SUV models are all the rage, and the 2026 Subaru Crosstrek is a perfect example of why. This SUV lets you take charge thanks to balanced performance, versatile interior space, and enhanced technology features. You can get more information on the Subaru Crosstrek when you read this model overview. Breaking Down the 2026 Subaru Crosstrek Performance One of the best ways to find out if a new SUV is right for you is to see how it drives and look at what’s under the hood. In the 2026 Crosstrek, its 2.5‑liter flat‑4 (BOXER) gasoline engine can generate as much as 180 horsepower, and when properly equipped, it will tow up to 1,500 lbs.. With such well-balanced performance, it's safe to say the Crosstrek isn't your dad's SUV. There are other performance features available for this model, such as: Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive 1,500 pounds maximum towing capacity 8-speed manual mode with paddle shifters Technology You want a SUV that can back up its driveability with proven technology, and that's why the Crosstrek is worth your time. With these amenities, a safe and intuitive ride is more than within reach — it's an expectation. The technology features of the Crosstrek don't end there. You'll also enjoy these: EyeSight® Driver Assist Technology Blind-Spot Detection with Lane Change Assist Auto Vehicle Hold (AVH) Design A next-generation SUV should boast a next-generation aesthetic, and the Crosstrek is crafted for the road ahead. The only problem you'll find with the 55 cu ft of cargo volume in the Crosstrek is deciding on what to do with all the space. And with interior refinements to match usability, the new Crosstrek is the reason you choose a SUV over other body styles. Below are a few more available design features of this SUV: Black folding side mirrors 17-inch dark gray-finish alloy wheels Two-speed windshield wipers with variable-intermittent mode and mist feature You can find the 2026 Crosstrek at Competition Subaru of Smithtown. Our inventory of new Subaru cars for sale is unmatched in this area. See what our regular rotation of new Subaru specials has in store for you today. *MSRP: Starting price represents the manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP) for the trim. The MSRP does not include destination and handling charges, taxes, title, license, options, and dealer charges. Actual prices are set by the dealer and may vary. Photo is for marketing and example purposes only. Photo may not reflect starting MSRP or trim level.\n**EPA-estimated MPG for City/Highway for 2026 Subaru Crosstrek . Actual mileage will vary. Displayed MPG is based on applicable EPA mileage ratings. Use for comparison purposes only. Your actual mileage will vary, depending on how you drive and maintain your vehicle, driving conditions, battery pack age/condition (hybrid models only) and other factors.

2026 Subaru Forester

The 2026 Subaru Forester Is Defined by All-Around Excellence

It doesn't get anymore modern than a SUV, and the 2026 Subaru Forester is as cutting-edge as they come. Roomy and comfortable, without sacrificing maneuverability, this entry from Subaru addresses every SUV driver's pain points. Looking for the scoop on the new Forester? Keep reading this overview. A Quick Look at the 2026 Subaru Forester Performance A SUV should maximize power without completely sacrificing fuel efficiency, a requirement that the new Forester achieves easily. Packing a Naturally aspirated flat‑4 engine, lack of get-up-and-go is never an issue in the Forester. All this power considered, the Forester still manages a composed ride with limited body roll. Check out even more of the available performance features here: Lineartronic® CVT (Continually Variable Transmission) with low shift mode 4-wheel independent suspension Vehicle Dynamics Control (VDC) Technology Forward-thinking is a mandatory trait for SUV models these days, and the new Forester is no exception. Add in seamless entertainment and navigation, and you have one of the most complete in-cabin experiences on the market. There are some other technology features listed below: Subaru Multimedia System Brake Assist Anti-theft security system Design You know the new Forester has a sturdy exterior, but have you seen what you can do inside? All of your personal effects — or however much of them you can fit into 74 cu ft — are accounted for in the Forester. This layout will have you wondering how you ever got around without the Forester. The Forester also offers the following: Black folding side mirrors Subaru advanced frontal airbag system Two-speed windshield wipers with variable-intermittent mode and mist feature You can find the 2026 Forester when you visit Competition Subaru of Smithtown. Our inventory of new Subaru cars for sale is unmatched in this area. Don’t forget to check our new Subaru specials for current offers, and we can set up a test drive at a time that works for you. *MSRP: Starting price represents the manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP) for the trim. The MSRP does not include destination and handling charges, taxes, title, license, options, and dealer charges. Actual prices are set by the dealer and may vary. Photo is for marketing and example purposes only. Photo may not reflect starting MSRP or trim level.\n**EPA-estimated MPG for City/Highway for 2026 Subaru Forester . Actual mileage will vary. Displayed MPG is based on applicable EPA mileage ratings. Use for comparison purposes only. Your actual mileage will vary, depending on how you drive and maintain your vehicle, driving conditions, battery pack age/condition (hybrid models only) and other factors.

The Subaru Impreza vs. The Honda Civic

For years, compact car shoppers have focused heavily on the Honda Civic, but another vehicle has quietly become one of the smartest values in the segment: the Subaru Impreza. With standard all-wheel drive, impressive safety technology, improving reliability rankings, and affordable certified pre-owned pricing, the Impreza is becoming an increasingly attractive option for drivers looking for long-term value. According to a recent feature from TopSpeed, lightly used Impreza models can often cost thousands less than a new Civic while still delivering modern features and excellent everyday practicality. Key Takeaways The Subaru Impreza includes standard Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive. Subaru ranks near the top of the industry in recent reliability studies. Subaru EyeSight safety technology continues to earn strong safety ratings. Certified pre-owned Impreza models can offer major savings compared to new compact cars. Naturally aspirated Subaru engines may provide simpler long-term ownership. The Impreza delivers strong value for commuters, families, and year-round drivers. Why The Subaru Impreza Deserves More Attention Standard AWD Gives The Impreza A Big Advantage One of the biggest reasons the Impreza stands out is Subaru’s standard Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system. In a segment dominated by front-wheel-drive vehicles, AWD gives the Impreza additional confidence during: Snowy winter driving Heavy rain Slippery roads Changing road conditions For drivers in colder climates or areas with unpredictable weather, that extra traction can make a major difference in daily driving confidence. Subaru Reliability Has Improved Significantly Subaru has made major strides in reliability over the past several years. Organizations like Consumer Reports have recently ranked Subaru near the top of the automotive industry for dependability and owner satisfaction. Part of that growing reputation comes from Subaru’s approach to engineering. Many Impreza models continue using naturally aspirated engines, which some buyers prefer for long-term simplicity and maintenance. Meanwhile, some online automotive discussions have raised concerns surrounding certain small turbocharged engines and CVT combinations found in competing compact vehicles. While experiences vary by owner, many drivers appreciate Subaru’s straightforward powertrain design philosophy. Subaru Safety Reputation Continues To Impress Safety remains one of Subaru’s strongest selling points. Many recent Subaru Impreza models include: EyeSight Driver Assist Technology Adaptive cruise control Lane departure warning Automatic emergency braking Blind-spot monitoring The Subaru brand also performs consistently well in crash testing conducted by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. For families and commuters alike, that reputation adds meaningful peace of mind. Certified Pre-Owned Impreza Models Offer Strong Value SIRR-IMAGE-5fe86225eb364b7f8644190f9d8825b0 As new vehicle prices continue climbing, many shoppers are turning toward certified pre-owned options. A certified pre-owned Subaru Impreza can often provide: Lower monthly payments Factory-backed warranty coverage Modern infotainment systems Advanced safety technology Reduced depreciation For buyers trying to maximize long-term ownership value, the Impreza has become an underrated option in today’s market. Why Drivers Are Choosing The Impreza The Impreza continues gaining attention because it checks several important boxes at once: Strong safety scores Standard AWD capability Improving reliability Practical hatchback versatility Lower used-market pricing That combination makes it especially appealing for commuters, first-time buyers, students, and drivers looking for dependable transportation without overspending. FAQs Does the Subaru Impreza come standard with AWD? Yes. Every modern Subaru Impreza includes Subaru Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive as standard equipment. Is the Subaru Impreza reliable? Subaru’s recent reliability rankings have improved considerably, with several industry studies placing the brand near the top for dependability and owner satisfaction. Is a certified pre-owned Subaru Impreza worth buying? For many buyers, yes. Certified pre-owned Impreza models often include modern safety features, warranty coverage, and lower pricing compared to new compact cars. What safety features does the Subaru Impreza include? Many Impreza models feature EyeSight Driver Assist Technology, adaptive cruise control, automatic emergency braking, and lane-keeping assistance. Why do buyers like naturally aspirated Subaru engines? Some drivers prefer naturally aspirated engines because they are often viewed as mechanically simpler over long-term ownership compared to smaller turbocharged engines. Final Thoughts The Subaru Impreza may not always receive the same attention as some rivals, but it has quietly become one of the best values in the compact car segment. With standard AWD, impressive safety technology, improving reliability rankings, and affordable certified pre-owned pricing, the Impreza delivers the kind of practical ownership experience many drivers are looking for today. For shoppers focused on safety, all-weather confidence, and long-term value, the Subaru Impreza deserves a serious look.